When people ask me about the best locked room mystery books, I can never give a single answer! The joy of this subgenre lies in the fact that the author locks the door, throws away the keys, and expects you to find it. These aren’t just neat puzzles; they’re mind games designed to mess with your sense of logic, trust, and even reality.
That’s why Agatha Christie’s And Then There Were None remains iconic. It isn’t just about “who did it,” but about themes that all the next books since have borrowed, reshaped, and reinvented. So if you loved Christie’s masterpiece, or simply want stories that will stretch your brain, we have 10 more books in store for you, that will make you feel the same.
Why Readers Love And Then There Were None
And Then There Were None remains the gold standard of closed circle mystery books. Ten strangers (each one with a shadowy secret) are lured to a mysterious and isolated island. Then, one by one, they begin to die; each death eerily echoing the lines of a sinister nursery rhyme pinned to the wall.
Here’s why readers love this Agatha Christie book so much:
- Christie uses the setup of a psychological cage to heighten paranoia and claustrophobia
- Readers adore its impossible mysteries; how can someone keep killing when everyone is accounted for?
- Its legendary ending is still one of the most shocking twists in all of detective fiction
It’s not just a guess-who book; it’s the ultimate study in guilt, justice, and human weakness. Each character is forced to confront the weight of their own sins, proving why Christie wasn’t merely a plotmaker but a master psychologist of crime.
10 Best Books Like And Then There Were None
If you loved Christie’s masterpiece, here are books like And Then There Were None. All are guaranteed to trap you in their pages. So, let’s dive in.
1. The Decagon House Murders by Yukito Ayatsuji
Setting: A remote island off Japan’s coast
The Decagon House Murders is a direct homage to Agatha Christie style writing, filled with secluded setting murders and a tight circle of suspects. A group of college students fascinated by classic locked room whodunits gathers at the eerie Decagon House to pay tribute to their favorite writers. However, they start dying in bizarre ways and that’s how the lines between fiction and reality collapse.
Excerpt:
“The six-sided clock ticked on with a steady beat, indifferent to the fear tightening their chests. Each of them sat in silence, listening, wondering whose heartbeat would be the next to stop. The Decagon House was no longer a curiosity; it was a trap.”
Like Christie, this Japanese writer uses the secluded island as a psychological trap, stripping away all outside interference. The dread builds with each chapter, and fans of Christie will savor the same slow, claustrophobic unraveling of trust: Who can you rely on when everyone might be the killer?
2. The Seven Deaths of Evelyn Hardcastle by Stuart Turton
Setting: A crumbling English mansion frozen in time
If Christie’s And Then There Were None thrilled you with its intricate puzzle mystery and air of inevitability, Turton’s novel takes that spirit and flips it on its head. It’s in Evelyn Hardcastle’s fate to die every day after 11 PM. The only way to break this loop is if Aiden Bishop identifies who the killer is. The twist? Aiden wakes up in a different body each day and is forced to see the murder from different angles.
Excerpt:
“How lost do you have to be to let the devil lead you home?”
The Seven Deaths of Evelyn Hardcastle has everything from the mind-bending logic of a time-loop thriller to a labyrinthine puzzle where trust is impossible. If you’re craving Christie’s ingenuity and a metafictional spin to it, this book by Stuart Turton is the perfect pick for you!
3. The Hunting Party by Lucy Foley
Setting: A snowbound lodge in the Scottish Highlands
The Hunting Party echoes Christie’s setup i.e. a group of friends isolated from the world and a killer hiding amongst them. Their New Year ritual of reuniting gets an interesting twist when they’re forced to meet in a remote lodge. When one of them turns up dead, old resentments resurface, and the true darkness of their friendships comes to light.
Excerpt:
“The snow has sealed us in. We are prisoners, each of us with something to hide.”
Like Christie, Foley thrives on the claustrophobia of suspects trapped in one place, but with a contemporary bite. Secrets of privilege, betrayal, and jealousy seep through every page. For fans who loved And Then There Were None’s confined terror and unraveling trust, The Hunting Party offers the same chills in a sharp, modern voice.
4. The Guest List by Lucy Foley
Setting: A wedding on a remote Irish island
We always think of weddings as celebrations, right? But not Lucky Foley…Her book, The Guest List twists the occasion into a nightmare of rivalries, grudges, and secrets. Amidst festivities, a body is found, and everyone present becomes a suspect. Cut off by rough seas and stormy weather, the island turns into a gilded prison.
Excerpt:
“The waves crash against the rocks, drowning out the scream that no one wants to admit they heard.”
If you’re looking for a modern and luxurious version of And Then There Were None, The Guest List is the perfect pick for you! For Christie fans, it’s a perfect cocktail of paranoia, betrayal, and shocking reveals.
5. One by One by Ruth Ware
Setting: A ski chalet in the snowy French Alps
I read One by One on a rainy afternoon, and what I loved was how much it echoed And Then There Were None but still managed to speak to today’s anxieties. A team of app developers gets stuck due to an avalanche, and one by one, they begin to disappear. But beneath this digitally tense narrative, Ruth Ware beautifully covers the themes of guilt, power, and the thin veneer of corporate camaraderie.
Excerpt:
“The snow pressed against the windows like a suffocating hand, erasing the world until only the house, and the danger inside it, remained.”
I love how Christie’s themes of guilt and justice are covered but also adapted to a modern workplace context, where ambition becomes fatal. It reminded me of heated startup cultures where loyalty is so fragile and betrayal often hides behind fake smiles.
RELATED READING: 10 Books Like My Dark Vanessa That Will Haunt You
6. Closed Casket by Sophie Hannah
Setting: A secluded country house in Ireland
The next in the list of murder mystery books in confined spaces is the continuation of Agatha Christie’s Poirot. A wealthy woman’s will sparks bitterness, suspicion, and ultimately her death. Detective Poirot is given the task to make sense of this murder, which takes place in a house full of secrets.
Excerpt:
“The house brimmed with suspicion, as though even the walls had been listening to the whispered threats.”
Closed Casket is the perfect tribute from Hannah to Christie, exploring themes like greed, family inheritance, and morality. It beautifully honors Poirot instead of reinventing it. Wondering how Hannah is able to achieve that? By placing him in a case full of contradictions. Like Christie, the novel probes the messy tangle of justice and human weakness, proving that classic crime fiction can evolve without losing its soul.
7. The Tokyo Zodiac Murders by Soji Shimada
Setting: Japan, spanning from 1936 to decades later
The Tokyo Zodiac Murders reminded me why I fell in love with impossible crime novels in the first place. The premise is chilling: a family massacre prophesied by an eccentric artist’s will, carried out with brutal precision, and left unsolved for decades. As a reader, I felt like I was solving the puzzle of codes, logic and superstitions right alongside the detective!
Excerpt:
“The stars had already sealed their fates, all that remained was the blood to fulfill the prophecy.”
But what struck me wasn’t only the intellectual satisfaction; it was how the novel captured the cultural weight of fate, superstition, and rationality clashing head-on. Christie focused on guilt and human weaknesses but Shimada’s books goes one step ahead to talk about destiny and deduction. As a reader, it left me exhilarated but also haunted, like I’d brushed up against something larger than the crime itself.
8. Shiver by Allie Reynolds
Setting: An abandoned ski lodge in the French Alps
Five former friends (all of them are competitive snowboarders) gather at the French Alps for a reunion. The twist? Their host never arrives and someone starts playing games with them. With a storm closing in, betrayal resurfaces alongside danger.
Excerpt:
“The cold wasn’t only in the air; it was in their voices, their glances, every word edged with secrets they couldn’t outrun.”
At its heart, Shiver is a story about competition, betrayal, and how ambition corrodes trust. Reynolds beautifully pairs the adrenaline of sport with the claustrophobic terror of a closed-circle mystery. Like Christie, she shows that the past is never buried; it waits, festering, until the right storm brings it back to life.
9. Murder on the Orient Express by Agatha Christie
Setting: A luxurious train stranded in the snow
The next in the list of mystery books with twist endings is Christie’s most audacious detective story. A man is found stabbed in his locked compartment aboard the Orient Express, and Poirot must solve the case before the train moves again.
Excerpt:
“The train lay stranded in the snowdrift, silent and still, as if holding its breath for the truth to be spoken.”
When I first read it, I was shook not just because it’s clever but also because it’s unsettling. Beyond the ingenious solution, the book wrestles with justice, morality, and collective guilt. For And Then There Were None fans, it’s a reminder that Christie’s puzzles always carry deeper questions about what humans are capable of when cornered.
10. The Crime at Black Dudley by Margery Allingham
Setting: A Gothic country house
If we’re talking about the best locked room mystery authors, we must talk about Margery Allingham. In The Crime at Black Dudley (his debut), he beautifully mixes Gothic atmosphere with whodunit tradition. Guests gather for a party at Black Dudley, but a strange ritual ends in murder.
Excerpt:
“The house itself seemed to brood over them, every shadow whispering of secrets best left unspoken.”
The best part is that Allingham has created a story that bridges Christie’s puzzle-driven mysteries with Gothic sensibilities. For fans of And Then There Were None, this offers not only a classic locked-room setup but also a glimpse into the broader Golden Age atmosphere that defined the genre’s roots.
With this, we come to an end of the best locked room mysteries. The above list will not only take away your night’s sleep but will also force you to confront the fragile nature of truth. And how when humans come under pressure,their flaws (of ambition, jealousy, greed, and fear) come out. And that’s why these stories still mess with us today: because long after the final reveal, the doubt, and the unease stay locked inside you.
So, which of these locked room mystery books is your favorite? Share your thoughts in the comments, and if you’ve got a favorite mind-bending mystery we missed, we’d love to hear your recommendations!
FAQs
1. What is a locked room mystery book?
It is a type of detective or crime novel where murders take place inside a closed setting like an isolated island or sealed room. So, the puzzle lies in how it was done.
2. What makes a locked-room mystery intriguing?
The thrill lies in the impossible setup. Readers feel like they are also solving the mystery along with the detective. At the end, the author flips logic and assumptions in a satisfying way.
3. Are locked room mystery books always set in a literal locked room?
No, it could be a stranded train or even a cut-off hotel. Basically, suspects are limited, and escape (or intrusion) is nearly impossible.
4. Can Young Adults read locked room mystery books?
Yes! While some classics and modern titles are darker or more complex, there are plenty of locked room mysteries written for adults who are young. They’re a great way to sharpen critical thinking while enjoying suspense. For example, One of Us Is Lying by Karen M. McManus works as a modern, YA-friendly take.
The Ultimate Fall Reading List: 9 Best Autumn Books To Read This Year
